Holiday 2017 vs. Holiday 2016: Apples to Apples, or Apples to Oranges?

Marshal Cohen

Chief Industry Advisor, Retail
@marshalcohen

Every year we talk about how the upcoming holiday season will compare to the prior, but sometimes that isn’t the best comparison to make.  

Understanding how the 2017 holiday season will measure up against the 2015 shopping season is potentially more accurate than looking at the 2016 season. The reason is that last year was an election year, which historically has a greater impact on the holiday shopping season. Election-year distraction goes deeper than other factors.

NPD’s latest Holiday Purchase Intentions survey shows that although the anticipated 2017 holiday spending is relatively equal to the 2016 holiday season, it is even closer to the 2015 season. While the shifts are slight, the good news is that regardless of the basis for comparison, the shifts are favorable.

Holiday 2016’s actual sales results were up less than two percent vs. 2015. As a result of the lack of election noise impacting shopping behavior, Holiday 2017 should be more in line with 2015, where we saw 3.2 percent sales growth.

While there are always external factors occurring that may be a distraction from holiday shopping, one holiday season is not like the last. We need to be aware of the bigger factors influencing consumer mindset, and ultimately consumer spending behavior to truly understand the consumer’s psyche heading into this important shopping season.

 *Source: The NPD Group, Inc. / 2017 Holiday Purchase Intentions Study

---

How COVID-19 is Impacting Consumer Spending

Get the Latest

Women Lead Kitchen and Bath Improvement Spending in the U.S., Reports NPD

Online or in store, women were more likely to buy kitchen and bath items than lawn and garden, paint, hardware, or other home improvement products last year.

Navigating the Road to Retail’s Repositioning

Whether looking to recover from a challenging year or remain relevant, all manufacturers and retailers need to find ways to reposition their business.

Pandemic Changes in Driving Drove Fuel Buyers to More One-Stop-Shop Options, Reports NPD

Many consumers are commuting less and limiting daily activities. As a result, fuel-buying visits declined but also became more focused on the one-stop-shop.

Consumers Take Grilling and Outdoor Cooking to the Next Level, Reports NPD

More than 14 million grills and smokers have been sold during the pandemic. Gains spanned nearly every type of product, and fall months led the retail growth.