Home Blog 2019 Will 5G Live Up To The Hype?
Jun 3, 2019

The Emperor Only Wears Underpants

Subscribe to our blog

I’m starting to get concerned that the marketing hype surrounding 5G will struggle to meet the reality of the situation. Beyond any technical reservations (we’ll get to those) there seems to be a growing sentiment that 5G will cause fundamental upheavals in society and business – the like of which have never been seen before. Consider me a skeptic, but I cannot help but think of the story of the Emperor who wore no clothes.

To be clear: I do believe in 5G and what it is capable of, but I also think we need to place the technology into the context of what already exists. After all, I have fiber to the home, so 5G will not have any impact there, as fiber and mesh Wi-Fi are better than I will ever get with 5G. As such, when I’m asked if 5G will drive more home schooling, or more connected devices in our homes, I start to get concerned about the reality warp.

So let’s take a look at the 5G basics, and particularly the spectrum that is being used. The 5G hype machine is focusing on the benefits of the millimeter wave spectrum – spectrum in the range of 39 GHz – that provides the super high bandwidth with low latency. It’s a great story to tell and yes, it’s a huge leap forward from LTE. But it comes with a rather significant drawback: the higher the spectrum frequency, the shorter the distance it will travel and the more susceptible it is to blockage. At 39 GHz, the signal can be blocked by almost anything: your hand, a tree, even glass. Oh, and hope it’s not raining as that can impact the signal too. The signal is also good for only a few hundred feet. As a result, the carriers need to install a lot of antennas to make this work and, realistically, it will be in open areas such as parks and arenas to start with… then slowly deploying in major cities as they get local government permission to install the additional technology.

At the other end of the spectrum, we have T-Mobile which plans to use 700MHz as the basis of its initial 5G. This spectrum also has benefits, but lacks the marketing appeal. The signal will reach further than current towers can, and it will be faster than LTE (although far from the blistering speeds currently hyped) particularly as T-Mobile works to migrate the current spectrum over to 5G in time to increase the available bands. This strategy is great for rural markets that need better signals, and explains why T-Mobile’s strategy includes a home-based solution for these underserved markets. According to NPD Connected Intelligence’s new Rural America Report,  an estimated 31 percent of all households do not currently have access to broadband service at home  and the vast majority of these underserved homes are in rural markets.

And then there is Sprint, which has mid-band spectrum in the 2500MHz range, thanks to its acquisition of Clearwire many years ago. The irony here is that the carrier with the least money to spend has probably the best spectrum for a compromised 5G: faster, and still capable of traveling reasonable distances. If the T-Mobile/Sprint merger does get approval, the joint company will be in the strongest position to provide a decent 5G solution. It still won’t be the super-fast, super-low latency that we’ve been promised anytime soon, but it will be much better than the current LTE.

Of course, the ideal solution would be to have all three bands: millimeter wave for densely populated areas, 2500MHz for the broader, high-speed solution, and 700MHz to give us the true coverage layer. Since no one carrier has all three assets right now, we need a reality check against the 5G hype. The Emperor is still wearing clothes… just not very many at this point.



Stay current in your industry
SUBSCRIBE


Technology is Saving Time Along the Path to Consumption
Technology is Saving Time Along the Path to Consumption

In a stressful moment for U.S. consumers, mealtime has turned into a mental escape from hectic days. People are searching for ways to make their lives easier. Convenience, long a consumer priority, has taken on new importance as consumers acquire and use new technologies to prepare or order food for meals mostly eaten at home these days. Is recent growth of kitchen technology here to stay?

U.S. Mobile Carrier Telesales Share Doubled in Q2 2020 Driven By COVID Restrictions
U.S. Mobile Carrier Telesales Share Doubled in Q2 2020 Driven By COVID Restrictions

As COVID restrictions eased in Q3 smartphone shoppers slowly returned to stores for their purchases. In fact, while retail has not returned to its typical share of the market, it gained back 11 market share percentage points from Q2 to Q3 2020.

Audiobooks: Double-digit Growth
Audiobooks: Double-digit Growth

Digital audio is one of the hottest content trends in the U.S., growing by double digits for the last three years. Here’s a look at our latest audiobook insights

2020 Baker’s Dozen: Stephen Baker’s Annual Holiday Tech Expectations
2020 Baker’s Dozen: Stephen Baker’s Annual Holiday Tech Expectations

We are expecting historic Q4 sales for consumer tech (+18%), but how will we get there? Read on to see the trends NPD’s Consumer Tech Industry Advisor, Stephen Baker, anticipates will contribute to this outcome.

Newsletter

Subscribe and get key market trends and insights relevant to your industry each month.

We will not sell your information. View privacy notice. | Cookie Settings

Follow Us

© 2020 The NPD Group, Inc.